Andrew Goulding.com HOME

 

 

Blue

 

"...Sad, spare, and beautiful, Blue is the quintessential confessional singer/songwriter album..." Amazon reviewer Deeyar

You know, it's taken me six months to write this review for Blue...I just couldn't get a handle on what I was trying to say...and this morning at 6.30 it came to me, so here it is: 

The problem is that, though a powerful album, Blue hardly has a song worth recommending on it!

Yes, there are tune-lets...but nothing that stands out. Instead, what you get is a truthful, oh-so-truthful blog of a transitional time in a young woman's life whose diary entries have been put to music (occasionally with the help of then-sometime lover James Taylor & friend Stephen Stills).

 

Joni Mitchell Blue

Joni Mitchell: Blue

 

These raw statements produce something unique and precious, quite unlike anything I've heard since. There's:

  • Love lost
  • Love gained
  • Love run away from
  • Love played with

...and underpinning it all, a melancholy that even if the right Love came along, Joni would sabotage it anyway. e.g. while Christmas reminiscing about her homeland, Canada's, winter...and her temperate home in California...she returns once more to the treatise on Love:

"...I'm so hard to handle
I'm selfish and I'm sad
I've gone and lost the best baby
That I e-v-e-r had
Oh I wish I had a river
I could skate away on..."

               River

 

...And yet, when later discussing a Love she'd left in Canada, her home...and the man...are little more than sentimental attachments: 

"...You're in my blood like holy wine
You taste so bitter and so sweet
Oh, I could drink a case of you, darling
And I'd still be on my feet!"

               Canada 

 

I remember reading a Joni Mitchell critic on Amazon saying:

"If only she'd had Prozac. We'd have been spared all this drivel." (paraphrase)

...and y'know, though I was angered at the time, the phrase stayed with me...because it's true. If Joni had taken Prozac, Blue would probably never have been created...and that's precisely why it's so valuable, because it's a remnant from a time:

when there were no boob jobs, extreme make-overs...or Prozac

when, 1965, if you had a child out of wedlock, you mostly gave it away for adoption  (Little Green) and wondered...or grieved for the rest of your life...

Joni Mitchell on Blue:

"...the point is, that soon after I'd given up my daughter for adoption I had a house and a car and I had the means and I'd become a public figure. The combination of those situations did not sit well. So I kind of withdrew from music and began to go inside. And question who I was. And out of that, Blue evolved. I guess I was being a 'shrink' to myself! And if I, in the process of doing that, found something I thought was universal..." Joe Jackson interview March 2000

 

...and the life of a promiscuous, guiltless hedonist seemed to fit hand and hand with that of a romantic, in the following instance, California, the place...and the man    

"...I met a redneck on a Grecian isle
He did the goat dance v-e-r-y well
He gave me back my smile
...But he kept my camera to sell

Oh, the rogue, the red, red rogue
He cooked good omelettes...and stews
And I might have stayed out there with him
But my heart cried out for you...

...California..."

                     California

 

Oh, but it wasn't California that was driving Joni, it was her endless needs, needs that she was unwilling to pay the price of satisfying...

"...Oh I am on a lonely road and I am
Travelling, travelling, travelling
Looking for something
What can it be?

Oh, I hate you some
I hate you some, I love you some
Oh, I love you
When I forget about me...

...I wanna talk to you
I wanna shampoo you,
I wanna renew you
Again and again

Applause, applause
Life is our cause
When I think of our kisses
My mind sees stars

Do you see...do you see
How you're hurting me baby?
So I hurt you, too
Then we both get...so...blue..."

And then finally, in this ridiculous...and utterly captivating song-cycle, we have Joni, pining once more for Love she won't pay for: 

"...But when he's gone
Me and them lonesome blues collide
The bed's too big
The frying pan's too wide..."

             All I Want

 

Joni Mitchell on Blue, again:

"...By the time of my fourth album {Blue, 1971}, I came to another turning point, the terrible opportunity that people are given in their lives. The day that they discover to the tips of their toes that they're assholes {solemn moment, then a gale of laughter}. And you have to work on from there and decide what your values are, which parts of you are no longer really necessary...they belong to childhood's end. Blue really was a turning point in a lot of ways...." Rolling Stone interview July 1979

 

There are other delights:

  • Blue
  • Carey
  • Little Green
  • the The Last Time I Saw Richard, a musical monologue rather than a song

...but I think you get the idea. Blue is not to be missed!

 

Joni Mitchell: Blue

"...This is perhaps my favorite album of all time. I want to hear it when I'm sad, and I want to hear it when I'm happy..." Amazon reviewer Karen J. Echols

"...Every once in a great while, an artist nails it...Blue may well be Joni Mitchell's Mona Lisa..." Amazon reviewer running_man

"...This album is so indicative of the hippie genre and how we lived it (and) Joni has captured that era in her songs...All the songs on this collection are awesome and they will stay in your head...for time immemorial. I love this music for the memories and the good feelings it creates now..." Amazon reviewer Karen D. Easton

"...What struck me the most about the album, after just a few listens, is how intimate it sounds...It's probably totally ridiculous but it was almost as if I felt she was singing just to me, FOR me, in a space that was occupied by just the two of us...She sings of simple things yet her lyricism is as rich as a fruitcake..." Amazon reviewer Olukayode Balogun

"...I remember when this album came out. I lived in a house with a group of friends. One guy was going through a break-up with his girlfriend and used to lock himself in his room and listen to River over, and over, and over again. Needless to say, it drove everyone nuts. However, this remains my favorite Joni Mitchell album...(and)...is essential listening for fans of any style of music.." Amazon reviewer Samuel B. King "Sam King"

"...I haven't taken it out of the CD player since I got it!..." Amazon reviewer Lu Ann Nye

 

Blue: Framed Edition

 

 

 

 

For more info, see:

 

 

 

 

 

Home

 

 

My book: The View From Bondi

The View From Bondi:

my book of short stories

& pop music soundtrack 

 

 

 

 

Pop Music

The Beatles

  • John Lennon
  • Paul McCartney
  • George Harrison
  • Ringo Starr

David Bowie

Todd Rundgren

  • Utopia

Joni Mitchell

King Crimson

  • Adrian Belew
  • Robert Fripp

Roxy Music

  • Bryan Ferry
  • Brian Eno

Albums You Should Know

 

 

Movies

  • Comedy
  • Cult
  • For Thought
  • Christopher Guest 
  • Historical
  • Mainstream 
  • Woody Allen

 

 

 

 

English Comedy

  • Peter Cook & Dudley Moore
  • Monty Python

 

 

 

 

A Thinking Man

  • Gurdjieff
  • Hitler 

 

 

Reduce Stress

 

 

 

Writings & Stuff

  • Articles
  • My Deepest Blog  
  • Jokes
  • Youtube Videos

 

 

 

Xango: the juice that changes lives

Xango: Yoga In A Bottle

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lose Weight

 

 

 

 

 

Site Map